Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is not a real condition. It was created through the combined influence of pharmaceutical companies and government regulators to put large numbers of vulnerable children on profitable psychiatric drugs, according to American behavioral neurologist Dr. Richard Saul.
After five decades of medical practice and evaluating thousands of patients who displayed the classic signs, Saul has reached a firm conclusion: “There is no such thing as ADHD.” The diagnosis, he argues, has spread rapidly in recent years. Official figures now claim that more than 4 percent of adults and 11 percent of children in the United States have been labeled with the disorder.
Almost everyone experiences moments of disorganization, mental drift, or sudden irritation. These everyday lapses are routinely treated as evidence of ADHD, and the default response has become medication. That reflex helps explain the sharp rise in prescriptions. Data released by Express Scripts showed that between 2008 and 2012 the number of Americans taking ADHD medication climbed 36 percent.
Saul maintains that the symptoms attributed to ADHD are in fact produced by more than twenty other medical conditions, including poor eyesight, chronic sleep deprivation, and bipolar disorder. When those underlying problems are correctly identified and treated, the attention and hyperactivity issues typically resolve. “In my view, not a single individual is afflicted by the disorder called ADHD as we define it today,” he writes in his book ADHD Does Not Exist.
The fundamental error, he says, is defining an illness by its symptoms rather than its cause. A runny nose can signal a cold, an allergy, or any number of other problems; the symptom itself is not a diagnosis. Saul’s argument has provoked strong reactions inside the medical community and among people who identify with the ADHD label. Whatever one’s position, the debate itself is useful: it encourages patients and physicians to look more carefully for the actual source of the symptoms instead of reaching automatically for stimulant medication.
The Express Scripts report itself concluded that the rising prescription numbers signal a need for closer scrutiny of how and why these drugs are prescribed, especially for adults, and for a fuller assessment of each patient’s overall situation before a prescription is written.
In an age of constant digital distraction, when attention is fragmented by design and multitasking is treated as a virtue, the surge in ADHD diagnoses should not surprise anyone. The conversation Saul has forced open suggests a different possibility: that one day the condition may be remembered simply as “the disorder formerly known as ADHD.”
Be the first to comment